| League | Date | Home Team | Score | Away Team |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CH | 04-05-2024 | Plymouth | 1 - 0 | Hull |
| CH | 27-04-2024 | Millwall | 1 - 0 | Plymouth |
| CH | 20-04-2024 | Stoke | 3 - 0 | Plymouth |
| CH | 12-04-2024 | Plymouth | 1 - 0 | Leicester |
| CH | 09-04-2024 | Plymouth | 1 - 1 | QPR |
| CH | 05-04-2024 | Rotherham | 0 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 01-04-2024 | Plymouth | 0 - 1 | Bristol City |
| CH | 29-03-2024 | Norwich | 2 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 16-03-2024 | Plymouth | 0 - 1 | Preston |
| CH | 09-03-2024 | Blackburn | 1 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 05-03-2024 | Sheffield Weds | 1 - 0 | Plymouth |
| CH | 02-03-2024 | Plymouth | 0 - 2 | Ipswich |
| CH | 24-02-2024 | Middlesbrough | 0 - 2 | Plymouth |
| CH | 20-02-2024 | Plymouth | 0 - 3 | West Brom |
| CH | 17-02-2024 | Plymouth | 0 - 2 | Leeds |
| CH | 14-02-2024 | Plymouth | 2 - 2 | Coventry |
| CH | 10-02-2024 | Sunderland | 3 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 03-02-2024 | Swansea | 0 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 20-01-2024 | Plymouth | 3 - 1 | Cardiff |
| CH | 13-01-2024 | Huddersfield | 1 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 01-01-2024 | Plymouth | 3 - 3 | Watford |
| CH | 29-12-2023 | Southampton | 2 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 26-12-2023 | Cardiff | 2 - 2 | Plymouth |
| CH | 23-12-2023 | Plymouth | 3 - 3 | Birmingham |
| CH | 16-12-2023 | Plymouth | 3 - 2 | Rotherham |
| CH | 13-12-2023 | QPR | 0 - 0 | Plymouth |
| CH | 09-12-2023 | Leicester | 4 - 0 | Plymouth |
| CH | 02-12-2023 | Plymouth | 2 - 1 | Stoke |
| CH | 28-11-2023 | Coventry | 1 - 0 | Plymouth |
| CH | 25-11-2023 | Plymouth | 2 - 0 | Sunderland |
| CH | 11-11-2023 | Leeds | 2 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 04-11-2023 | Plymouth | 3 - 3 | Middlesbrough |
| CH | 28-10-2023 | Ipswich | 3 - 2 | Plymouth |
| CH | 25-10-2023 | Plymouth | 3 - 0 | Sheffield Weds |
| CH | 21-10-2023 | West Brom | 0 - 0 | Plymouth |
| CH | 07-10-2023 | Plymouth | 1 - 3 | Swansea |
| CH | 03-10-2023 | Plymouth | 0 - 2 | Millwall |
| CH | 30-09-2023 | Hull | 1 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 23-09-2023 | Plymouth | 6 - 2 | Norwich |
| CH | 19-09-2023 | Bristol City | 4 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 16-09-2023 | Preston | 2 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 02-09-2023 | Plymouth | 3 - 0 | Blackburn |
| CH | 26-08-2023 | Birmingham | 2 - 1 | Plymouth |
| CH | 19-08-2023 | Plymouth | 1 - 2 | Southampton |
| CH | 12-08-2023 | Watford | 0 - 0 | Plymouth |
| CH | 05-08-2023 | Plymouth | 3 - 1 | Huddersfield |